The highlight of the book is Maggie starts eating healthier, adding fruit to her diet and exercising. Which is all good, if the author had stopped there. Instead he takes is farther and before you know it Maggie has become thin and popular, and a star on her school's soccer team.
Now this is not necessarily a mom blog, or a dieting blog for people who have just found this one posting. However, in this instance I will get on my soapbox. In my refrigerator you are going to find butter, not margarine, not oleo, but the real deal. You are also going to find whole milk. Nothing less. I ran into a gentleman at the dairy section who was amazed that fat free milk had more sugar the two percent. And he gave me the funniest look when I said "Well, they have to put something in it to make it taste good after taking out all the fat." I also usually have cream, because I make my own whip cream to go on the various baked goods that I make using real butter and whole milk. What we don't have are a lot of fruit drinks, and I try to keep down on the high fructose corn syrup, and we do eat whole grains more often then not. Quinoa and Farro are awesome, in fact I have been able to keep them in the house more so then plain rice.
Now I have a four year old daughter. So I have a vested interest in upcoming entertainment releases. She is in the target range for this book, and I will never show it to her. And I will be one pissed of mother if someone else forces it on her. I understand, Grace is not as heavy as Maggie is. Even with her eating real butter and cream. And eating real baked goods made with real sugar, brown and white. However she also doesn't just sit in front of the t.v. all day, and she doesn't have a handheld gaming device either. But she plays, and she plays hard, she loves to go to the park. And she loves to play catch. Besides young children should not be encouraged to be thin like a supermodel, or even thin like teenagers. In fact healthy children should not be overly thin. They shouldn't be overly heavy either but they shouldn't be trying to have washboard abs. They need the extra to grow properly. It's a fact that women who don't have enough body fat stop menstruating, so what do we think happens to children who are still growing who don't have enough.
My biggest problem with the story is that Maggie got thin and became popular. It didn't stop with she was able to play an entire soccer game, which takes a lot of physical endurance, and cardio, and a lot of strength to be able to do, without needing to sit out the last half or be taken out of the game. She didn't overcome a medical problem, like getting her diabetes under control where she didn't have to take medication for it or help her blood pressure. The story is that if you are thin you will be popular. Why because children that age are literal. They can't read between the lines and be able to pull a higher lesson out of this book, I mean the book has pictures to convey they meaning and the pages rhyme. So yes please tell me how this book is supposed to help my daughter come to the realization that she will have more self confidence if she makes healthy lifestyle choices. I can tell you what she will get out of it is that she will be teased if she is heavy, that the teasing will make her become an emotional eater, but if she starts eating healthy AND loses weight then she will be popular and the other kids will want to know her name.
Also just because you eat more fruits and vegetables and get more active, doesn't mean that you will become thin. This idea that people keep pushing about dieting equals thinness ignores things like genetics and bone structure. Some people have bigger muscles then others, guess what that means. They are going to be bigger then the thin kids. All are issues that are ignored.
Are kids going to call each other names and bully each other, yes they will. As humans we've been doing for centuries. But we need to make sure that our children know that different is o.k., and that doing something for popularity is not a good enough reason to do anything. I know I was in school once and I hope that I can teach Grace to be strong enough that there are other things more important than being popular. Like graduating.